討論:臺灣通過跨國同性婚姻：港澳及外國人士適用 唯中國除外

範圍

How can Taiwan decide, that in Hong Kong marriage is valid? Thought China has its own law. Regards, Conny（留言） 2023年1月21日 (六) 09:45 (UTC)

Hong Kong has its own legal system which is different from China's. HKSAR recognizes some overseas same-sex marriages. Kitabc12345（留言） 2023年1月21日 (六) 17:45 (UTC)

Although it seems like they're not looking at the law. Some Hong Kongers are moving to Taiwan, also known as the "Hong Kong People's Garden", as a result of the 2019 anti-China political protests. People in Taiwan think that Hong Kong people are different from Chinese people. But Taiwan's calculation may be to marginalize mainland Chinese sentiment, and many Hong Kong and Macao residents actually like Taiwan, so he may decide to treat Hong Kong people differently, because they understand that Hong Kong people are different from Chinese people, especially in terms of political views, universal values and personality. Kitabc12345（留言） 2023年1月21日 (六) 17:52 (UTC)

However, in fact, there is some discrimination in this regard, because as far as I know, men or women in mainland China can come to Taiwan to marry with heterosexual couples, and another partner from mainland China has obtained Taiwan's Republic of China nationality. Some groups have raised questions about the aspects you raised:

Https://www.rfa.org/mandarin/yataibaodao/gangtai/hx1-01202023073508.html

In a word, Taiwan may be more sensitive to mainland China, but this actually affects some people. Although same-sex marriage is illegal in China, it is allowed to be notarized by the government. I don't know whether the so-called Chinese nationals with Taiwan compatriot certificates can marry mainlanders in this way. / ／

不過其實這方面有一定的歧視，因為就我所知目前中國大陸的男子或者女子可以來台灣與台藉異性伴侶結婚，來自中國大陸的另一伴更獲得台灣的中華民國國籍。有團體就這你提出的方面提出疑問：

https://www.rfa.org/mandarin/yataibaodao/gangtai/hx1-01202023073508.html

總括來說，台灣或者對中國大陸比較敏感，但是這樣其實亦都影響到部份人士。中國來說雖然同性婚姻不合法，不過是允許政府公證的，我不清楚擁有台胞證的所謂中國國民能否能夠透過這樣與大陸人士結婚。 Kitabc12345（留言） 2023年1月21日 (六) 21:54 (UTC)

Thank you. That means in conclution, that Taiwan say: Humans can marriage in Taiwan, also if they come from Hong Kong or Macau - but not, if they come from People's Republic of China? Conny（留言） 2023年1月22日 (日) 06:37 (UTC).

Yes. You say rights. Kitabc12345（留言） 2023年1月22日 (日) 08:22 (UTC)

In the future, no matter which country Taiwanese foreign partners come from or Hong Kong and Macao, even if that country does not recognize gay marriage, these gay couples can legally marry in Taiwan and start a family legally. But people from PPC, just not. sadly…… Kitabc12345（留言） 2023年1月22日 (日) 08:26 (UTC)

Taiwan's this year government has very poor relations with China. The voice of resisting China and protecting Taiwan continues, and the number of Taiwan weavings to prevent the China mainland from invading Taiwan has increased year by year then in previous years. Tsai Ing-wen or Su Zhenchang may consider this reason. Mainland heterosexual couples are fine. In fact, same-sex couples are not treated fairly at all. Kitabc12345（留言） 2023年1月22日 (日) 08:39 (UTC)

Thank you for explanation. Regards, Conny（留言） 2023年1月22日 (日) 13:44 (UTC)

Can you say/give a source when in future it is possible to come from any country of the world? Conny（留言） 2023年1月22日 (日) 13:46 (UTC)

I don't know. At present, it is actually all countries in the world (except China). As for the timetable for opening up China, it is really not clear at present. You can contact Taiwan's non-profit organizations and government departments to inquire about individuals, because they have not announced the timetable, and unfortunately, the Taiwanese government I think is does not want to open up China… sadly… Kitabc12345（留言） 2023年1月22日 (日) 16:28 (UTC)